I like iTunes. A lot. This is a significant thing for me to say, because I was an apprehensive adopter a few years ago due to a fear of having to reorganize my entire music collection. I realize that there are much larger libraries out there, but at the time, having to go through and check 20 gigs of music file by file to make sure it was imported properly was at best an irritation and at worst a nightmare. So thanks for making that business fairly simple business so long as a few key pieces of information are present.
As my collection of music has grown larger over time, I've noticed that the ability of iTunes and my iPod to keep up has not progressed quite as much. This isn't something that I immediately noticed; as long as I don't make my tags complex and simply label everything as the artist that released the album, or lump various artist releases together as a compilation, there's very little trouble at all. The problem is that I can't necessarily lump *all* of my music up in ways that are currently convenient for you to sort, and that creates trouble for me. Let me give you a rather long example.
Let's say that I decide I want to rip Soulwax's Most of the Remixes... to my library, and then proceed to do so. You've got this nifty little section in the song information for "Album Artist," which for this particular album is pretty darn convenient. Given that the songs on the album are originally written, recorded, and performed by one person or group, and that another person as remixed it into something new, it'd be nice to be able to search for either the original artist or the DJ to find the song, and this option allows me to do that. Obviously, for this particular album, the artist is Soulwax, which would make them the Album Artist. The original artists my be anyone from Muse to DFA to Gorillas, so obviously they'd be the Artists. So now when I browse iTunes, I can find either the whole album under Soulwax, or the individual tracks under the name of the artist that originally performed them. This is damn simple, so thanks for that.
Working in reverse is not so simple. Take Beck's Guerolito. Applying the above logic, obviously Beck would be the Artist, because he's the one that wrote and performed the songs. The DJs and artists remixing the songs for this particular album, like Soulwax, would probably fit nicely into Album Artist. Except not. When I do this and attempt to sort the album by Artist, or Album by Artist, or Album by year, the entire list of tracks is borked and out of order because iTunes is sorting the tracks alphabetically by Album Artist, which you'll notice I totally didn't ask it to do. And while I understand there's a quick fix made by reversing who's listed as Album Artist and who's listed as Artist, it really doesn't make much sense to say that the DJs are the original artists, and that Beck is just the guy releasing it. I mean, it's his music. On top of that, if I resort to this and drop it all onto my iPod, the album won't be showing up under Beck's heading if I choose to browse by Artist, but will instead be scattered about under the names of all of the DJs that appear on the album.
To make matters worse, when Album Artist does actually work, there's no implementation for it on the iPod. Like, no way at all. You can't browse by Album Artist, you can't sort by it, you can't even read the song notes to see who it might be. And yet the iPod is somehow crazily and paradoxically built, like iTunes, to sort tracks out by the Album Artist instead of the track number. What the deuce? If I pull up Beck, Guerolito, as an album, I'd like it to play in order. That's kind of the idea of listening to the whole album; I'm having a very hard time understanding why on the one hand, Album Artist isn't significant enough to be a searchable or even usable factor on the iPod, but then on the other hand I can't make my music NOT sort alphabetically by Album Artist when I pull up a full album. Am I crazy? Does this make sense to other people?
I know I'm not the only person in the history of ever to bitch about the Album Artist category and how it kind of ruins lives, so what gives? How about more custom sorting strings (or in the case of the iPod, any at all)? Or how about reconfiguring some defaults, like if I look at an album it's automatically sorted by track number unless I specifically tell it to do something else? Your smart playlists are pretty damn awesome at letting users set up certain criteria for what shows up on a list; why not give users the option to do that with sorting out their own libraries, too? "Sort by Artist, then Year, then Track#." Somehow I have the faith that your programmers are capable of making this apparently insane fantasy into something real.
That said, I have my doubts that you ever will; you've created a terrifically user friendly program. It is, in fact, so terrifically user friendly that it can't do nearly as much as some of us would like it to, and I get the impression that you'd rather keep things overly simple for new users than allow more familiar users to let the program do a bit more for them. It's cool, I get it. But it would be very, very nice if iTunes could do all the little things I'd like it to instead of giving me hell for asking.
-J